Island Club Market Update & Community Insight

St. Simons Island Club Market Update – December 30, 2025
Presented by Dave Burton, Realtor® | Keller Williams Realty

Island Club on St. Simons Island continues to attract strong buyer interest, especially for well-maintained golf-course community homes priced between $1.2M–$1.7M, while larger luxury properties remain available for buyers seeking space and long-term value.

Current Listings & Recent Activity (Last 14 Days)

(A = Active | P = Pending | S = Sold)

  • A | Carnoustie
    4 Bed | 3 Bath | 1991 – 3,005 SF – 0.42 Acre – $1,250,000 – 7 DOM

  • A | Augusta
    4 Bed | 3 Bath | 1989 – 3,825 SF – 0.43 Acre – $1,250,000 – 67 DOM

  • A | Saint Andrews Drive
    3 Bed | 2 Bath | 1992 – 3,555 SF – 0.51 Acre – $1,495,000 – 105 DOM

  • A | Troon
    4 Bed | 4 Bath | 1985 – 3,125 SF – 0.38 Acre – $1,595,000 – 120 DOM

  • A | Merion
    3 Bed | 3 Bath | 1985 – 3,253 SF – 0.42 Acre – $1,595,000 – 145 DOM

  • A | Medinah Retreat
    4 Bed | 4 Bath | 1990 – 3,536 SF – 0.62 Acre – $1,695,000 – 85 DOM

  • A | Merion
    5 Bed | 4 Bath | 1986 – 6,204 SF – 0.40 Acre – $1,800,000 – 347 DOM

  • A | Biltmore
    4 Bed | 5 Bath | 1996 – 4,044 SF – 0.44 Acre – $2,549,000 – 24 DOM

  • P | Biltmore
    3 Bed | 2 Bath | 1985 – 2,006 SF – 0.46 Acre – $1,185,000 – 83 DOM

  • S | Pine Tree
    3 Bed | 3 Bath | 1990 – 3,000 SF – 0.45 Acre – $1,699,000 – 24 DOM

Market Insight: Homes that are priced correctly in Island Club are moving, while larger luxury homes benefit from strategic marketing and patience.

If you’re considering selling in Island Club or want a free home valuation, or if you’d like to schedule a private tour of available homes on St. Simons Island, I’m here to help.

Dave Burton, Realtor® | powered by Keller Williams

St. Simons Island Club Community Highlight

Living in St. Simons Island Club on St. Simons

St. Simons Island Club neighborhood Located within the prestigious Sea Island Golf Club, The Island Club at St. Simons is one of the most sought-after gated neighborhoods on Georgia’s coast. Residents enjoy a blend of luxury living, golf course views, private amenities, and proximity to the beach, all within minutes of shopping, dining, and the Village area. Homes range from elegant custom estates to modern Southern classics with lush landscaping and timeless design.

Homes in St. Simons Island Club

  • Homes range from 3-bedroom cottages to expansive estate-style residences, many featuring golf course, lagoon, or wooded views.

Lifestyle & Amenities

Living in St. Simons Island Club means access to a full-service lifestyle community, including:

  • 18-hole championship golf course

  • Clubhouse with dining & social events

  • Tennis courts, fitness center & pool

  • Gated security with beautifully maintained streets

  • Easy access to beaches, the Village, and Sea Island amenities

Why Buyers Choose St. Simons Island Club

Buyers are drawn to St. Simons Island Club for its exclusivity, lifestyle, and prime location. The community offers a blend of luxury and tranquility—perfect for primary residences or second homes. Families love the proximity to top-rated schools, golf enthusiasts appreciate the world-class greens, and everyone enjoys the sense of community that defines this prestigious neighborhood.

Logo featuring three evergreen trees with text promoting a conservation sale supporting forests and wildlife

FAQ

  • What makes The Island Club one of the premier neighborhoods on St. Simons Island?

    The Island Club offers a unique combination of security, prestige, and coastal beauty. This gated community features golf-front homes, tree-lined streets, and access to the Sea Island Golf Club, making it one of the most desirable addresses on the island. Its central location allows easy access to beaches, schools, and the Village, while maintaining a peaceful residential atmosphere.

  • What types of homes are available in The Island Club?

    Buyers will find a mix of custom-built single-family homes ranging from 2,000 to over 7,000 square feet. Many properties feature golf course or lagoon views, private pools, and spacious lots. Architectural styles include Lowcountry, Coastal Traditional, and Mediterranean-inspired estates, reflecting the community’s refined coastal lifestyle.

  • How is the real estate market performing in The Island Club?

    The Island Club remains one of the strongest luxury markets on St. Simons Island, with homes typically priced between $1.1M and $3M+. Demand is steady, especially for updated properties and those with water or golf course views. Inventory remains limited, keeping values strong and days-on-market relatively low compared to other areas.

  • What amenities are available to Island Club residents?

    Residents enjoy private gated entry, beautiful walking paths, and close proximity to the Sea Island Golf Club and The Lodge. Many homes overlook the fairways or lagoons, and membership options may include golf, tennis, fitness, dining, and spa access through Sea Island Resorts. The neighborhood’s natural beauty and manicured grounds make it ideal for those seeking luxury and leisure.

  • Is The Island Club a good fit for families and retirees?

    The Island Club is known as an ideal balance for families, professionals, and retirees. Its quiet streets, community feel, and proximity to top-rated Glynn County schools, local churches, and beaches make it highly desirable. Many residents enjoy an active lifestyle with biking, golfing, and boating right at their doorstep.

  • How can I buy or sell a home in The Island Club?

    I provide custom home valuations, strategic marketing, and private tours for qualified buyers. Whether you’re exploring your first coastal property or listing a luxury estate, my goal is to make your Island Club real estate experience seamless and successful.

    📞 Contact Dave Burton, Realtor® | Keller Williams Realty
    Serving with Integrity. Selling with Purpose.

Complimentary Property Valuation

Complimentary Property Valuation with No Pressure- Just Market Intelligence

Discreet + Private